Recent polling indicates that Vice President Kamala Harris is emerging as a favored contender among Democrats should President Joe Biden withdraw from his reelection bid following concerns over his recent debate performance. While the Biden campaign has reaffirmed the president’s commitment to continuing his candidacy, speculation persists within Democratic circles about potential alternatives.
A flash poll by Data for Progress conducted among 1,011 likely U.S. voters, including 387 Democratic likely voters, highlighted Harris as the top choice to replace Biden, garnering 39 percent of Democratic respondents’ support in a hypothetical scenario where the party would need to select a new nominee through a convention. California Governor Gavin Newsom followed with 18 percent, while Transportation Secretary Pete Buttigieg secured 10 percent.
The discussion around Biden’s candidacy reflects broader divisions within the party. According to the polls, a significant portion of Democrats—51 percent—believes Biden should remain the presidential candidate, whereas among all likely voters, only 35 percent share this view. A Morning Consult poll conducted after a recent debate similarly underscored doubts among Democratic and independent voters about Biden’s candidacy, with a notable percentage suggesting he should be replaced.
The prospect of replacing a sitting president poses challenges and uncertainties for the Democratic Party. Thomas Gift, an associate professor of political science at University College London, pointed out that while an alternative candidate might offer potential advantages, any replacement would face intense scrutiny and potentially negative public opinion once thrust onto the national stage.
Biden himself has addressed concerns about his performance, acknowledging his challenges while affirming his ability to lead. During a recent rally, he emphasized his experience and commitment to the presidency, declaring that he wouldn’t continue running if he didn’t believe he could effectively fulfill the role.
Elaine Kamarck, a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution and a Democratic National Committee member, outlined several scenarios through which Biden could potentially be replaced as the Democratic nominee. These scenarios include Biden voluntarily stepping aside before the convention, facing challenges from other contenders for delegate support, or withdrawing post-convention, leaving the DNC to nominate an alternative candidate to face the Republican nominee, presumed to be Donald Trump.
As the Democratic Party navigates these dynamics, the focus remains on Biden’s continued candidacy, the party’s unity, and its strategy for the upcoming election. The unfolding narrative underscores the complexities and uncertainties inherent in presidential politics, particularly in the midst of evolving public opinion and electoral dynamics.