A new migrant detention center deep in the Florida Everglades—dubbed “Alligator Alcatraz”—is drawing unexpected criticism from two of the state’s top Catholic leaders, even as President Trump’s immigration policies continue to deliver historic drops in illegal crossings.
The facility, located on a remote military-style airstrip near Big Cypress National Preserve, has been praised by many conservatives for prioritizing border enforcement and national security. However, Miami Archbishop Thomas Wenski and Bishop Frank Dewane of Venice are voicing concerns over conditions at the site and the rhetoric used by some officials in defending it.
Faith Leaders Weigh In on Tough Policies
In a July 3 statement, Archbishop Wenski criticized what he called “alarming” enforcement tactics, taking issue with public comments referring to “alligators and pythons” as natural deterrents. “It is unbecoming of public officials and corrosive of the common good,” Wenski wrote, emphasizing that detained migrants are often parents and family members, not hardened criminals.
Bishop Dewane echoed those concerns, cautioning against language that dehumanizes individuals and warning that the center’s conditions may violate standards of basic human decency—especially given its distance from medical services and Florida’s intense summer weather.
Trump’s America First Agenda Still Popular
Despite the criticism, both bishops acknowledged that President Trump’s efforts to deport violent offenders and secure the southern border are supported by many Americans—particularly in communities affected by drug trafficking and gang violence.
They did, however, urge policymakers to remember that many undocumented immigrants are not violent but “law-abiding and hardworking.” Bishop Dewane noted the administration’s recent creation of a farm visa program, which allows seasonal workers to legally support Florida’s agriculture sector, as a positive step.
DeSantis Defends Facility: “This is About Security”
Florida Governor Ron DeSantis has vigorously defended the site, calling it “an excellent location for security and enforcement operations.” He stressed that the facility’s purpose is not comfort but effective processing and deportation of those who entered the country illegally.
“This is about law and order, not luxury,” DeSantis stated. “Our job is to keep Florida safe.”
Legal Battles and Public Scrutiny Continue
Several state lawmakers have filed lawsuits after being denied access to inspect the facility, raising additional questions about transparency and oversight. Civil liberties groups and environmental advocates have also voiced opposition, citing concerns about wildlife impact and detainee welfare.
As the 2026 midterms approach, the debate over how America handles immigration—especially under the renewed leadership of President Trump—is likely to remain front and center. While many faith leaders call for compassion, millions of Americans are demanding strong, decisive action to protect the nation’s borders and uphold the rule of law.