Senate Democrats are firmly rejecting the notion that Justice Sonia Sotomayor should step down from her position on the Supreme Court, despite suggestions from left-leaning activists and commentators. The argument draws parallels to the aftermath of Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg’s passing four years ago.
At 69, Sotomayor is the eldest among the liberal justices, prompting some progressives to urge her resignation while Democrats maintain control of both the White House and the Senate. They fear a repeat scenario of Ginsburg’s decision not to retire in 2014, which led to her passing in 2020 and the subsequent appointment of a conservative justice by former President Trump, tilting the court to a 6-3 conservative majority.
Concerns about Sotomayor’s health, particularly her Type 1 diabetes, fuel these calls for resignation. However, Senate Democrats stand by her, emphasizing her vigor and competence.
Senator Peter Welch underscores that Sotomayor is not yet 70 and exhibits exceptional competence, dismissing comparisons to Ginsburg’s situation. Senate Judiciary Committee Chair Dick Durbin echoes this sentiment, expressing his desire for Sotomayor to remain on the bench.
Many Democrats express bewilderment at the notion of Sotomayor stepping down, citing her exemplary performance and absence of signals regarding her intentions. Senator Chris Van Hollen praises her work and Senator Elizabeth Warren dismisses the discussion as “nonsense,” expressing gratitude for Sotomayor’s service.
The conversation gained traction after Senator Richard Blumenthal cautioned Democrats to learn from past mistakes, referencing the replacement of Ginsburg with Justice Amy Coney Barrett shortly before the 2020 election.
Despite concerns about a potential Republican resurgence in the next election, Democrats remain adamant about retaining Sotomayor, acknowledging her distinguished 15-year tenure.
Sotomayor herself acknowledges the increased workload and demands on the court, expressing fatigue but emphasizing her commitment to the role and its impact.
The calls for her resignation also stir opposition from groups reluctant to see the first Latina justice step down. The Congressional Hispanic Caucus praises Sotomayor’s brilliance and fair adjudication, expressing anticipation for her continued service.
In essence, Senate Democrats are standing firmly behind Justice Sotomayor, rejecting calls for her resignation and emphasizing her competence and value on the Supreme Court.