As New Jersey gears up for the 2025 gubernatorial election, Republicans are seizing a rare opportunity to challenge Democratic dominance in the state. The unexpected closeness of the 2024 presidential election, where Vice President Kamala Harris only managed to carry New Jersey by a slim 6-point margin over President Trump, has emboldened GOP strategists. This marks the closest the state has come to a Republican win in over three decades, following a similarly tight race in the 2021 gubernatorial contest, where Democratic Governor Phil Murphy won by just over 3 points.
With Murphy now term-limited, Republicans see 2025 as a prime opportunity to flip the governor’s mansion. According to New Jersey GOP strategist Alex Zdan, the state’s political landscape is more competitive than ever. “This is a moment for Republicans to capitalize on the momentum from Trump’s strong performance in New Jersey,” Zdan said, noting that a crowded field of GOP candidates could yield a strong contender to challenge the Democratic establishment.
New Jersey, long considered a solidly Democratic state, hasn’t voted for a Republican in a presidential race since 1988 and hasn’t elected a Republican senator since the 1970s. However, the state does have a history of electing Republican governors. In recent years, Republicans have seen significant gains, especially in 2024, where the state experienced one of the largest swings away from Democrats compared to the rest of the country.
Part of the Democrats’ struggles can be traced to voter turnout in key northern counties, traditionally Democratic strongholds like Hudson, Essex, and Passaic. As local political machines in these areas weaken, some experts argue that the Democratic Party has become complacent, neglecting grassroots organizing and alienating voters with their failure to address the economic challenges many face. “The Democrats have failed to adapt their message to the changing concerns of New Jerseyans,” said Jersey City Mayor Steven Fulop, a Democratic gubernatorial candidate.
On the other side, Republicans are rallying behind a mix of establishment figures and grassroots conservatives. Jack Ciattarelli, who ran against Murphy in 2021, is positioning himself as the moderate, while Bill Spadea, a conservative talk-radio host, is drawing on his support among Trump’s base. These two heavyweights dominate the Republican field, but other potential candidates include former state senators and local leaders, making it unclear who will ultimately secure the nomination.
For the Democrats, the 2025 election is already shaping up to be a challenging one. The state’s primary will feature a crowded field of Democratic candidates, including U.S. Reps. Mikie Sherrill and Josh Gottheimer, Newark Mayor Ras Baraka, and others. However, the elimination of the “county line” ballot, a unique feature of New Jersey elections where candidates from the same county party appear on a single line on the ballot, could make the Democratic primary even more unpredictable.
Despite these internal challenges, Democratic strategists believe the party still holds an advantage in a state that traditionally leans blue. However, they acknowledge that the recent election results are a “wake-up call.” “We have to focus on kitchen-table issues like affordability, housing, and the cost of living,” said Democratic strategist Henry de Koninck. With the economic strain on working-class families, both parties will be vying to address these concerns as the 2025 race heats up.
For Republicans, the momentum is palpable. As GOP strategist Jeanette Hoffman noted, the party has made inroads with voter registration, seeing more Republicans register than Democrats in recent years—a shift that could signal broader political changes. With voters increasingly dissatisfied with the status quo, Republicans believe they have a genuine shot at winning the governor’s office in what has traditionally been a blue state.
In the coming months, both parties will have their work cut out for them. While New Jersey has historically been a stronghold for Democrats, the combination of a weakened Democratic machine, voter discontent, and a competitive Republican field could make the 2025 gubernatorial race one of the most unpredictable and closely watched in the nation. For Republicans, it’s clear that this is a moment they cannot afford to miss. New Jersey, once considered a safe blue state, is now a legitimate swing state.